"Nothing is more difficult, and therefore more precious than to be able to decide."
Napoleon Bonaparte
An essential trait of a leader is being decisive- the ability to make decisions quickly and effectively. Often, at the senior leadership level, leaders are not presented with two best options but two terrible options, and making a decision based on those becomes a challenge. The role of the leader is not to make the most popular decision but to make the hard choices that have the best chance of success in the long term and are aligned with the values and goals of the organization.Â
Decisive leaders are seen as individuals with solid integrity, good at solving problems, and able to move the organization beyond known boundaries by establishing stretch goals.
Here are some insights on the pros and cons of being decisive and indecisive in leadership from research conducted by John Zenger and Joseph Folkman on extraordinary leadership attributes.
Pros:
Display Integrity:Â Â Decisive leaders assess facts and are fearless in making informed decisions with available data, even when there are areas of ambiguity. They convey a sense of integrity, honesty, and transparency. This fosters trust among team members, bolstering morale and productivity.
Efficiency Enhancement:Â Setting deadlines for decisions ensures timely resolution of issues, preventing prolonged deliberation that can impede progress. Decisive leaders instill a sense of urgency, driving momentum and efficiency within the team. They are seen as the ones who make things move.Â
Clarity in Responsibility:Â Leaders clarify roles and responsibilities by deciding who will make the final call or establishing decision-making processes. This minimizes confusion and empowers team members to act decisively within their spheres of influence.
Enhanced Team Buy-in:Â Effective decision-making involves maximizing team buy-in, ensuring that decisions are correct and embraced by those tasked with implementation. Leaders who skillfully communicate decisions and motivate their teams cultivate a culture of collaboration and commitment.
Cons:
Perceived Indecision:Â Protracted decision-making processes can breed skepticism among team members, leading to doubts about a leader's motives and integrity. Delayed decisions may be interpreted as evasion or concealment of relevant information, undermining trust and cohesion.
Potential for Misalignment:Â Teams may encounter disarray and conflicting priorities without clear deadlines and decision-making protocols. Lack of clarity regarding who decides what can lead to decision paralysis and hamper progress.
Resistance to Unpopular Decisions:Â While decisiveness is crucial for imposing stretch goals and making tough choices, unpopular decisions such as project elimination or layoffs may face resistance. Leaders must navigate this challenge tactfully, balancing organizational needs with employee morale.
Critical Strategies for Enhancing Decisiveness:
Set Clear Deadlines:Â Establishing deadlines for decisions prevents delays and stagnations and propels people to act and solve problems instead of letting them fester.
Define Decision-Making Authority:Â Determine who holds responsibility for making critical decisions, the process to be used for making the decision, and ensure accountability and clarity within the team.
Cultivate Team Buy-in:Â Decisions are executed exceptionally well on the ground when the team feels that they have been part of the process or have been taken into confidence or communicated well. Effective decision-making hinges on garnering support from team members. Leaders must adeptly communicate decisions, outline roles, and motivate teams to endorse and implement them.
Decisiveness is a linchpin of effective leadership, embodying integrity, problem-solving prowess, and the courage to set and achieve stretch goals. Leaders can propel their teams toward success amidst complexity and uncertainty by embracing decisiveness and employing strategies to mitigate its drawbacks.
Decisive leaders project integrity, conquer challenges, and reach new heights. Be Decisive.
Leadership Coaching Questions
How can you enhance your decision-making process to ensure it reflects integrity while effectively addressing complex problems?
What strategies can you implement to cultivate a culture of decisiveness within your team, emphasizing problem-solving and alignment with higher organizational goals?
How can you leverage your decisiveness as a leader to inspire others, foster collaboration, and push the boundaries of what your team can achieve?
Leaders Poll
What would make you more decisive as a leader and create impact?
Deal With Ambiguity
Set Clear Process and Deadlines
Seek Team Input
Communicate Clearly
